Welcome to Front Street Pizza Keyport
Front Street Pizza Keyport, nestled at 42 W Front St, Keyport, NJ, is a beloved pizza joint renowned for its exceptional food and welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the perfectly crafted pizzas, including their beloved Sicilian and the standout "Old Fashioned" pie, which boasts a unique upside-down style. The sweet sauce and well-balanced cheese create an unforgettable flavor. Moreover, the menu offers delightful specialties like meatballs, sausage and peppers, and chicken francaise, all praised for their quality. With friendly staff and stunning bay views, Front Street Pizza isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a community favorite where great food meets warm hospitality.
Front Street Pizza Keyport: Reviews & Ratings
We had the best experience with Front Street Pizza. I’m not usually a review-leaver kind of person but we were so impressed with the place that we had to write something. I had the food catered to my house for two separate graduation parties and the food was a hit at both parties. I am a snob when it comes to meatballs and theirs was so good that I ordered a bigger tray for the second party (because it all went!). The sausage and peppers, chicken francaise and penne a la vodka were also so yummy. The people there are also very kind and easy to order from. I would recommend them to all.
Absolutely love the pizza here. Pictured is a well done large plain pie. The sauce is slightly sweet. Perfect amount of cheese. Excellent crunch on the crust and almost no flop. Confident in declaring this my favorite traditional plain pie in NJ. Employees are always very friendly. Food is always hot and fresh. If you haven’t given this place a try, you are missing out!
I am happy that I discovered this place. If you love a Sicilian slice, this place has the best one in the area. Their Old Fashioned is an upside down Sicilian pizza and it is by far the best one I have had in New Jersey. My kids love the plain slices here (they are very picky about their pizza) and my wife and I prefer the speciality pies. We have not had anything other than pizza here but we really enjoy it here. The place is clean and has great views of the bay from the windows. The staff here are very nice and they make a great pizza.
Awesome pizza place! Good pizza, good staff, good service.
The food was amazing. The plain pizza and margarita pizza were absolutely delicious! The staff was super friendly and outgoing, and they were quick to get our food out to us. Love the atmosphere and I will definitely be back when I’m in the area!
I’d like to preface this by saying I’m generally a tough critic when it comes to restaurant reviews.. Back in April our team of roofers was working on a few projects down the street and needed a pizzeria to consistently deliver high quality satisfying lunch meals. For three days straight Front Street Pizza EXCEEDED our expectations by being punctual, courteous, and of course making some delicious pizza and subs. There are a few good restaurant options in the area, but I’m excited to officially have a new go-to lunch spot. Great job guys. Beautiful spot, comfortable atmosphere, and most importantly amazing food. Keep up the good work
Amazing pizza !!! This is my favorite pizza place EVER and everyone I bring here agrees. Whenever my friend from North Jersey visits the FIRST place she wants to go is Front St Pizza. The pizza is truly out of this world. Also everyone who works here is so nice and so kind especially Sam! :)
Sam, Richard (public servant), Nick (public servant), Sham, Adam, are great humans who make and love pizza and garlic bread and great community.
Location
-
42 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735, United States Hotline: +1 732-264-2667
Welcome to Front Street Pizza Keyport, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Keyport, NJ. Located at 42 W Front St, this delightful pizzeria is renowned for its exceptional offerings and warm hospitality. You can reach them at +1 732-264-2667 for any inquiries or to place an order.
What sets Front Street Pizza apart? The pizza, undoubtedly! Customers rave about the traditional plain pie, which boasts a slightly sweet sauce, ample cheese, and a perfectly crunchy crust. Michael Smith, a loyal patron, declares it his favorite in New Jersey. For those who favor variety, the Sicilian slice won’t disappoint. As one customer shares, the Old Fashioned Sicilian pizza takes the standard to new heights, delivering an unforgettable dining experience.
The menu extends beyond pizza; it's a canvas of flavors. Christine deSimas praises their catering service from delicious meatballs to flavorful chicken Francaise and satisfying penne a la vodka. Their meatballs are particularly noteworthy, prompting her to order an extra tray due to their popularity at graduation parties. This speaks volumes about the quality and taste that Front Street Pizza continually delivers.
Beyond the food, the friendly and attentive staff deserve a mention. Visit Karlos Paul’s review for a glimpse of the vibrant atmosphere that enhances every meal. The restaurant’s clean interior and scenic views of the bay create a perfect backdrop for enjoying delectable dishes with friends and family.
In essence, Front Street Pizza Keyport isn’t just a place to grab a slice; it's an experience of culinary delight. Whether you're savoring their famous plain pie, indulging in specialty pizzas, or exploring their catered options, there's something here for everyone. Don’t miss out on the chance to experience what might just be your new favorite pizzeria.